Apr 27, 2004 17:35
20 yrs ago
Russian term
wrist-like motions (derivative from http://www.proz.com/kudoz/696147)
Russian to English
Tech/Engineering
Physics
This is a continuation of the question
http://www.proz.com/kudoz/696147, and all I need is a comment (comments) upon using this term for the motions described therein, after expaining once with the use of "modified breast stroke" analogy
http://www.proz.com/kudoz/696147, and all I need is a comment (comments) upon using this term for the motions described therein, after expaining once with the use of "modified breast stroke" analogy
Proposed translations
(English)
5 | another attempt at commenting | Alexander Demyanov |
Proposed translations
3 hrs
Selected
another attempt at commenting
I take an issue with the "wrist-like motion" option.
"Breast stroke" is a good analogy because breast stroke is a specific form in swimming. The term means a specific motion pattern.
Wrist, on the other wrist, is just a part of anatomy and can move in different manners or patterns. In my opinion, if you prefer to stay within the wrist metaphor, it would be better to say something like "wrist wrestling motion" or use the wordy "wrist screwing in a light bulb motion" once and then refer to it as "screwing wrist motion".
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 20 hrs 55 mins (2004-04-28 14:31:05 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
I would also scan various martial art sources. I am sure there are forms/moves in martial arts very similar to the movement you are describing. Pick the name of one of the better known Aikido, Jujuitsu, etc., moves and before long everybody will use your paper for reference when trying to find a good term for the movement.
"Breast stroke" is a good analogy because breast stroke is a specific form in swimming. The term means a specific motion pattern.
Wrist, on the other wrist, is just a part of anatomy and can move in different manners or patterns. In my opinion, if you prefer to stay within the wrist metaphor, it would be better to say something like "wrist wrestling motion" or use the wordy "wrist screwing in a light bulb motion" once and then refer to it as "screwing wrist motion".
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 20 hrs 55 mins (2004-04-28 14:31:05 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
I would also scan various martial art sources. I am sure there are forms/moves in martial arts very similar to the movement you are describing. Pick the name of one of the better known Aikido, Jujuitsu, etc., moves and before long everybody will use your paper for reference when trying to find a good term for the movement.
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer.
Comment: "Thanks a lot! If curious - stimulated by all inputs, I found "wing-warping" (pre-airleron direction control of aircrafts, circa 1910), and "[articulate] humming-bird like motions" (contrary to what might seem, it dosn't just flap the wings, it also warps them and contracts the fingers - our sceletons are not that different..
"
Discussion
On the subject - I fully realize that "wrist-like motions" do not convey the idea. The problem is that some of "eggheads" whose English is not native might might be not familiar with the expression "brest stroke". Besides - the alleged motion is more complex than that anyway - the key is the coupling of separation of two "wings" (or palms) connected through the "body" (or with wrists bound) with the rotation. To make it more complex - these two processes are also coupled with the "palm" (this analogy surely works better here) "grabbing" something (the "fingers" bent somewhat and two "apples" get latched within). Moreover, later in the process a couple of "plums" get stuck between the heels of the palms (near the wrist). The rotation/advance coupling alone, for instance, would be well conveyed by Kalashnikov assault gan gas lock analogy.
[Un]fortunately, this analogy might be strange for most of the western people. So, my thinking was that since there is no precise analogy anyway, perhaps a simplest (though the most remote) one should be used for a short name.
However, you comment, especially the wrestling part of it, is to the point, and I'll certainly keep the kung-fu idea in mind.
By the way, the clarification part was mostly thinking out loud, though to an imaginary audience, which sometimes helps to concentrate, and also intended to satisfy curiosity that might have arisen from the question. I'd surely apreciate further comments/ideas, but am also fully prepared to close the question real soon.