| דפים בנושא: [1 2] > | Poll: Do you believe that no word is untranslatable? מפרסם התגובה: ProZ.com Staff
|
|---|
| |
Words are just words. Our job is to convey meaning. Where there is no obvious direct translation, we just express the meaning in some other way. That's our job. That's why we still have a role in a world with Google Translate. For now.
That's not to say some words aren't complete pigs to translate, obviously.
| | | | neilmac
ספרד
Local time: 10:14
מספרדית לאנגלית
+ ...
Probably NO, but I'm far too busy actually working to take time out for philosophical ponderings. UK newspapers and magazines keep teling us that the Danish "hygge" is untranslatable, but that's patently nonsense.
| | | |
Chris S wrote:
Words are just words. Our job is to convey meaning. Where there is no obvious direct translation, we just express the meaning in some other way. That's our job. That's why we still have a role in a world with Google Translate. For now.
That's not to say some words aren't complete pigs to translate, obviously.
Absolutely.
| | |
|
|
|
There are certain words that have a specific flavour that is not 100% conveyable into another language - or perhaps into some languages it is, but not into all. I am bilingual by birth, translate between 3 languages, have studied 7 and understand a couple more.
And the Swedish "fika" is not easily rendered into a "merienda" in Spanish.
And the "prou" expression in Mallorquín is not quite the same as "stop, that's enough" (and that's 4 words for 1).
So yes, we can translate an... See more There are certain words that have a specific flavour that is not 100% conveyable into another language - or perhaps into some languages it is, but not into all. I am bilingual by birth, translate between 3 languages, have studied 7 and understand a couple more.
And the Swedish "fika" is not easily rendered into a "merienda" in Spanish.
And the "prou" expression in Mallorquín is not quite the same as "stop, that's enough" (and that's 4 words for 1).
So yes, we can translate and we can explain and even add a footnote, but the feelings and culture associated to some specific words can be very tricky to convey.
"Mysigt" in Swedish is similar to "Cosy / Cozy" in English, but I haven't found a satisfactory term in Spanish that makes me feel the warmth in my back with the feeling of that fluffy blanket while I see the dim light in the room, the nice temperature, perhaps soft music and good company. ▲ Collapse
| | | |
Certain words are more difficult to translate than others, but every concept should be translatable in some way in the target language, what happens is that every now and then there is no direct equivalent in just one word. As Chris says, that's our job!
| | | |
Although not all words can be translated "perfectly", I think there are excellent equivalents that sound just as good in the target language.
For ages they've been claiming the Portuguese saudade is untranslatable, but there's a Romanian word expressing the exact same thing/mood/feeling.
Besides, there's no general answer to this question, unless by someone who speaks all the languages in the world. It depends on what language you translate into. Some words are difficul... See more Although not all words can be translated "perfectly", I think there are excellent equivalents that sound just as good in the target language.
For ages they've been claiming the Portuguese saudade is untranslatable, but there's a Romanian word expressing the exact same thing/mood/feeling.
Besides, there's no general answer to this question, unless by someone who speaks all the languages in the world. It depends on what language you translate into. Some words are difficult to translate into a certain language, but very easy to convey in another one. ▲ Collapse
| | | | Muriel Vasconcellos (X) 
ארצות הברית
Local time: 01:14
מספרדית לאנגלית
+ ...
We can try, but I agree with Leticia that sometimes it's impossible to evoke the identical feeling. I think we are fooling ourselves if we believe that we can.
| | |
|
|
|
Mario Chavez (X)
Local time: 04:14
מאנגלית לספרדית
+ ...
| Words aren't just words | Nov 10, 2016 |
Consider the word “stop” and it evokes various meanings. But that word can also be made into an artwork. It is still a word but with an added layer or patina.
The fact that a word is comprised of one or several letters, in and of themselves a sign, a symbol, a graphic element, is often (and sadly) forgotten. We could say that letters and words are highly specialized forms of graphics, whether they're from a Roman alphabet, a Hebrew script or a Chinese calligraphy sheet.
... See more Consider the word “stop” and it evokes various meanings. But that word can also be made into an artwork. It is still a word but with an added layer or patina.
The fact that a word is comprised of one or several letters, in and of themselves a sign, a symbol, a graphic element, is often (and sadly) forgotten. We could say that letters and words are highly specialized forms of graphics, whether they're from a Roman alphabet, a Hebrew script or a Chinese calligraphy sheet.
Some words are untranslatable in some contexts, even in readable texts. You could also say that some of these words translate into white space, and that's okay. ▲ Collapse
| | | |
Leticia Klemetz, CT wrote:
And the "prou" expression in Mallorquín is not quite the same as "stop, that's enough" (and that's 4 words for 1).
Oh dear. In Piedmontese dialect (northern Italy, very close to the French border in my case), "Prou" has the same meaning.
| | | | neilmac
ספרד
Local time: 10:14
מספרדית לאנגלית
+ ...
Leticia Klemetz, CT wrote:
And the "prou" expression in Mallorquín is not quite the same as "stop, that's enough" (and that's 4 words for 1).
So yes, we can translate and we can explain and even add a footnote, but the feelings and culture associated to some specific words can be very tricky to convey.
"Mysigt" in Swedish is similar to "Cosy / Cozy" in English, but I haven't found a satisfactory term in Spanish that makes me feel the warmth in my back with the feeling of that fluffy blanket while I see the dim light in the room, the nice temperature, perhaps soft music and good company.
"Prou" is also common parlance in Valencia too. When doing TEFL, I sometimes signed off my classes with "prou for now"....
In Spain we probably get a similar feeling to "mysigt" when finding we have air conditioning...
| | | |
Definitely no
There are lots of words in Japanese that evoke a feeling and cannot be translated since they express a concept in a cultural context that is far, far different from anything that can be expressed in English. At a push and a shove, just maaaaybe the concept could perhaps be relayed in English orally by pronunciation or subtle nuances in delivery. However, you could never capture that feeling by the written word.
| | |
|
|
|
Diana Coada (X)
הממלכה המאוחדת
Local time: 09:14
מפורטוגזית לאנגלית
+ ...
Translation is not just about finding that perfect equivalent, far from it.
Annamaria Amik wrote:
Although not all words can be translated "perfectly", I think there are excellent equivalents that sound just as good in the target language.
For ages they've been claiming the Portuguese saudade is untranslatable, but there's a Romanian word expressing the exact same thing/mood/feeling.
Hear, hear! I'm especially worried when it's translators themselves perpetuating the myth of the untranslatable word. I see your saudade and I raise you my mioritic.
| | | | Thayenga
גרמניה
Local time: 10:14
חבר (2009)
מאנגלית לגרמנית
+ ...
There are a few words, e. g. "yelo" in Lakota, that simply cannot be translated because they have no meaning of their own. "Yelo" only empathizes what has been said, serving almost like a double confirmation, both in the positive as well as in the negative phrases.
| | | | | 'Hygge' is 'untranslatable' because it has at least dozen different meanings | Nov 10, 2016 |
neilmac wrote:
Probably NO, but I'm far too busy actually working to take time out for philosophical ponderings. UK newspapers and magazines keep teling us that the Danish "hygge" is untranslatable, but that's patently nonsense.
It is one of those words that covers a very wide spectrum of meanings, and on its own it is just too vague to define. Basically, it is something like enjoyment, but you can enjoy anything from total absorption in a book or a hobby to merry outings or parties. As a verb, it can be done alone or in good company. Planning and preparing is definitely part of the fun.
There is possibly an atmosphere - Danes associate it with candlelight, but that is not an invariable ingredient by any means. Any self-respecting family activity or holiday place claims to provide hygge, but there are plenty of adult forms of hygge too.
There may not be an equivalent single word that covers everything in other languages, but that is very different from untranslatable.
| | | | | דפים בנושא: [1 2] > | To report site rules violations or get help, contact a site moderator: You can also contact site staff by submitting a support request » Poll: Do you believe that no word is untranslatable? | CafeTran Espresso |
|---|
You've never met a CAT tool this clever!
Translate faster & easier, using a sophisticated CAT tool built by a translator / developer.
Accept jobs from clients who use Trados, MemoQ, Wordfast & major CAT tools.
Download and start using CafeTran Espresso -- for free
Buy now! » |
| | LinguaCore |
|---|
AI Translation at Your Fingertips
The underlying LLM technology of LinguaCore offers AI translations of unprecedented quality. Quick and simple. Add a human linguistic review at the end for expert-level quality at a fraction of the cost and time.
More info » |
|
| | | | X Sign in to your ProZ.com account... | | | | | |
Login to reply/comment 
